When more managers across different departments become irritable and employees do not stay, it is worth looking beyond individual personalities. Is the workplace relying on someone's patience to absorb vague instructions and excessive workloads? If employees keep filling gaps in decisions while managers receive no support either, hard work is unlikely to leave behind a system that makes the next job easier.
Irritability alone, however, cannot establish why people leave or what an entire company's culture is like. Pay and conditions, working hours and personal circumstances also matter. This article offers ways to examine recurring workplace problems, rather than a diagnosis of any particular company or person.
Not knowing what the work is for can be exhausting in itself
Difficult work requires expertise, time and cooperation. There is also another kind of effort: making an assignment clear enough to begin.
A document with no known reader. A meeting with no clear decision to make. A request to collect information already shared in everyday work, without explaining how it will be used. Each may be manageable alone. Having to guess the purpose afresh every time is a substantial burden.
Try to agree at least the following with the person assigning the work:
- What it is for and which decision it will inform
- When it is needed and in how much detail
- Who makes the decision and who does the work
- How it ranks against other tasks
- How far this assignment should go and what does not need doing
Some work cannot be fully defined at the outset. In that case, share what remains unknown and who will decide it by when. The problem is less the uncertainty itself than making someone proceed through it, then treating the consequences as entirely their fault.
Vague instructions followed by “Don't act on your own” leave decisions with nowhere to go
Suppose an employee proposes using an official checklist to narrow down the cause of an unexplained problem. Their manager stops the proposal: “What will that tell us? I'll ask someone else.”
The question itself is reasonable. Stopping an unnecessary investigation can be a valid decision. But stopping one route requires setting out the next:
- What would the proposed check fail to establish?
- Who will be asked instead, about what, and by when?
- While waiting, which tasks should stop and which can continue?
- Who will decide what to do with the answer?
If the proposal is blocked and the alternative inquiry never moves forward, the work is stalled with the decision-making ball still in the manager's hands. Demanding more initiative from the employee does not move that ball.
“You mustn't proceed on your own” cannot be combined with “I don't want responsibility for deciding.” Before adding more checks, agree who will decide and the deadline for doing so.
When can a hardworking employee become an irritable manager?
Someone is capable, so people rely on them. They are relied on, so they receive more work. Yet their authority, staffing and management training do not increase. In that situation, effort may keep absorbing pressure without creating any breathing room.
Being good at the practical work does not automatically equip someone to develop people or distribute workloads. When a team is not moving forward, several questions need to be considered separately: Are expectations clear? Do people have authority to make the necessary decisions? Is there too much work?
With little capacity left, a manager may become afraid to delegate and intervene in every detail. Or they may avoid being approached for help altogether. Repeated irritable responses can make employees reluctant to raise issues. Less information reaches the manager, leaving them with an even poorer grasp of the situation. This is a possible vicious cycle, not an inevitable path for everyone.
The WHO fact sheet on mental health at work identifies excessive workloads, low control, unclear roles and insufficient support among workplace risks. Irritability alone cannot tell us someone's level of competence or mental state.
Considering the environment does not excuse intimidation or insults. Managers need support, and the workplace also needs clear boundaries around unacceptable behavior.
To distinguish an individual problem from workplace culture, look at what is tolerated
Vague instructions, objections raised after the fact and decisions left unattended recur under different managers. Suggestions for improvement meet with “We're busy; it can't be helped” or “That's how I was treated.” Such common patterns are a reason to examine how the organization operates, as well as individual behavior.
Conversely, if reports lead to action and changes in workload or instructions, there may be room for improvement. Look beyond the number of irritable people to what the organization stops and what it allows to continue.
Employees may stop volunteering information, avoid their managers and protect themselves by doing only what is required. The workplace can become quiet while its problems remain. Reading that silence as an absence of dissatisfaction makes it easier to miss the problem until someone leaves.
Before recruiting more people, examine where you are losing them
Advertise, interview, hire, lose someone, advertise again. If people do not stay despite the effort put into recruitment, it may be like pouring water into a bucket with a hole in it.
That does not make every departure a manager's fault. Rather than merely comparing the number of departures by department, consider differences in headcount, roles, tenure, workload, pay and conditions. In a small team, a single departure can move the figures substantially.
Useful questions include:
- At what stage after joining do people most often leave?
- Is there a gap between what was explained before hiring and the actual job?
- Are training and someone to consult available?
- Are there shared problems with workload, assignments, evaluation or working hours?
- Who acted on difficulties raised in check-ins, and what changed?
When asking why someone is leaving, focus less on uncovering a supposedly hidden “real reason” and more on making it safe to speak and summarizing findings without identifying individuals.
Recruitment can build reusable knowledge and systems too. But if people leave for the same reasons and those reasons do not inform the next assignment or training plan, the effort can remain an endless exercise in filling holes. Turning effort into an asset means the next person no longer encounters the same obstacle.
Giving people autonomy is different from abandoning decisions
A manager who stays out of the details is not necessarily a bad manager. If goals and boundaries are clear, advice is available when needed, and someone resolves competing priorities, this can be a good way to delegate.
But if the manager does not pay attention, decide, protect the team or reflect results in evaluations, the employee is closer to carrying everything alone than enjoying freedom.
The UK HSE's Management Standards examine work-related stress through six areas: demands, control, support, relationships, role and change. This offers a useful prompt to examine support and roles alongside autonomy.
Managers do not need to watch everything. They need to clarify goals, responsibilities, priorities and decision deadlines, stop unnecessary work and adjust unreasonable workloads. Reducing waits for decisions and avoidable rework does more to make the next task easier than demanding more personal grit.
Try to improve things without taking on the job of rescuing the workplace alone
Within your own remit, keep brief records of proposals, decisions, the people responsible and deadlines for a response. A note that makes the next person's action clear is more useful for moving work forward than a record written to assign blame.
For the earlier example, you could write:
“I proposed an initial check to narrow down the cause, but the decision was to seek confirmation through another route. We are currently waiting for a response from the person responsible. Please confirm the response deadline and which work we may continue in the meantime.”
If problems persist despite such records, consider someone beyond your direct manager, HR, a worker representative or an available advice service. Record the necessary work-related facts, and do not take confidential company or customer information away without authorization.
A transfer or a different job may also be an option. Resigning immediately is not the best choice for everyone. Consider income, daily life, health and prospects for the next job, including whether time off or another form of distance could help. If difficulty sleeping or persistent, significant distress is affecting daily life, available healthcare or occupational health support may also be important.
Look at whether today's effort makes work easier for the next person
In a workplace with increasingly irritable managers, the question is not only who is at fault. Who fills the gaps in instructions? Whose decision is holding up progress? Are the same problems being passed on to the next person?
Alongside recruitment, clarify roles, adjust workloads and enable consultation and decisions to move forward. That is how daily effort can leave behind a system that makes subsequent work easier.
You are not obliged to build that system alone. Try improvements within your reach, and create distance if needed. You can reconsider how and where you work before exhaustion takes a further toll on you and those around you.

